Bill Jones, CEO of Luminate Education Group, responds to the Milburn report
Milburn’s recommendations rightly focus on earlier intervention, expansion of apprenticeships and improving pathways from education into work. Earlier intervention, expanded apprenticeships, stronger pathways into employment and better access to support are all essential. In Yorkshire and the Humber alone, 16% of our 16-24-year-olds are currently not in education, employment or training (NEET). Yes, as the review highlights, seven in ten of those young people want to be contributing and taking up places in employment or training. Our responsibility is to ensure that the opportunities and support they need are available.
The challenge is not simply to create more education and training opportunities, but to build a more coherent system in which young people can access them, move between them and progress successfully.
At Luminate Education Group, we believe this requires a genuinely tertiary approach to education and skills: one that brings together schools, further education, sixth forms, universities, employers and other partners around the needs of learners and communities. Academic knowledge and technical skills should not be competing alternatives, and young people should not face unnecessary barriers because of the boundaries between institutions, qualifications or funding systems. Education should work around the learner, rather than expecting learners to navigate a fragmented system.
We welcome the recognition that tackling this crisis requires a coordinated approach. As an anchor institution, sitting on NEET Task Forces in Leeds and Bradford, we are already leading the way in addressing regional NEET challenges.
Colleges, employers, schools and local authorities all have a role to play in identifying people at risk of becoming NEET and ensuring they have access to the right support and guidance
The Youth Opportunity Service would be a useful addition in bringing together careers advice, education opportunities and health/mental health services. Colleges must be central partners in both the design and delivery of this Service. It will allow us to work closely with WYCA to coordinate a clear approach to transitioning young people into education and long-term employment.
At Luminate Education Group, we work with more than 700 employers, giving us strong links to local industries and an understanding of the skills they need. These relationships help us shape relevant training, create progression routes and connect more young people with employment opportunities. We stand able to become a key delivery partner, and ensure that the legal guarantee of a clear pathway into education or employment is met.
Milburn proposes doubling the number of young people undertaking apprenticeships over the next decade, positioning them as an equal mainstream option to higher education for school leavers. We welcome this, and given sufficient resources and funding, we will be able to work with our local employers to expand our apprenticeship offer.
With the proposed 10% of the apprenticeship budget allocated to mayoral authorities, this will allow for our excellent relationships with West Yorkshire Combined Authority and York and North Yorkshire Combined Authority to grow and we will continue to work closely with them to address regional skills shortages and connect young people to sectors in high demand.
From our experience, one of the biggest barriers that employers face in taking on more young people are financial concerns. We agree with the proposal of grant funding for employers taking on more NEET young people, alongside the proposed changes to employer National Insurance thresholds for younger workers. Young people cannot take up employment if jobs are not available, and these changes are a positive step to allow employers to create more opportunities.
Health is also a major factor that Milburn is right to outline. We know that more than half of our NEET young people report having a health condition. Alongside the Youth Opportunity Service, we wholeheartedly agree with the recommendation to provide faster access to mental health support, fast-tracked for our NEET young people. These measures will make a real difference to our young people. This is an opportunity to work collectively across the education sector, with early intervention in schools and our communities so that health is no longer a barrier to earning or learning.
It is very welcome that Milburn recognises tackling this crisis requires a significant expansion of further education places. The report calls for 150,000 additional places each year by 2036. This scale of ambition is exactly what is needed to address the heart of the challenge we face. At Luminate, we have continued to operate at capacity for a number of years. Each year we enrol additional young people despite not having guaranteed extra funding. Across the Group, there are currently over 600 young people on waiting lists throughout our provision. This is underpinned by the almost 400 students we have on our books that we currently do not have the funding for.
We cannot have a situation where colleges are asked to do more without additional in year resource. To provide more opportunities for young people, we require sustained investment to expand access and meet the need.
Expanding access to further education, apprenticeships and employment support will require adequately funded college places, investment in facilities and equipment and sustainable funding for teaching and learner support.
Further education must be central to addressing this challenge. As the report recognises, colleges are central to delivering the vocational training, skills development and establishing the employer connections to help young people move into sustained employment.
The ambition of the review is clear, and there is real potential to transform the lives of young people and generations to come. We look forward to the Government’s forthcoming White Paper and hope it recognises the significant investment needed to turn these ambitions into reality.
With the right resources and funding, we are ready to step up and play our part in giving young people across Yorkshire the opportunities to succeed.
